The first thing that'll hit you when you start playing this game (which is also known as London Spirit Detectives) is how visually beautiful it is. Rather than using tile-based maps like most 2D RPGs, every area is instead a big, handcrafted unique piece of pixel art (with a few minor exceptions, like the bits of steam machinery seen in various locations that I think are copy-pasted sprites). Making the game about a detective agency is a great bit of game design thinking that ties into this, too: since you'll be taking on various cases in the same city, it means these bespoke graphics can be used throughout the game, unlike a typical RPG, where you'd be travelling the world, visiting lots of places that'd all need their own graphics making.
It adds up to a game that feels like a combination of the upper-tier of PS1 RPGs like Grandia or Breath of Fire III and Iv, with higher brow eighties kids anime like Sherlock Hound and GRimm Meisaku Gekijo. Very nice and cosy. The theme is strengthend by the way it handles the accumulation of money! Unlike most RPGs, where you just get money along with your experience points after every battle, you instead get a wage from your boss (you play as a pair of apprentice detectives) after every solved case, and there's also abounty program in place by the city council, and when you kill "vermin" (rats, stray cats and dogs, etc.), you can go to the council offices and claim a reward. Which means that human enemies like muggers and street gang kids don't get you any money at all! It's a little more clunky than most games in the genre, but like I said, it just adds to the theming, and I think that more than cancels out the inconvenience.
Unfortunately, all that praise has to come to an end. I just really didn't enjoy playing the game for very long. Firstly, while so much work and imagination has gone into making the game's world fit its theme, the actual play itself doesn't so much. Rather than finding and following clues yourself, you're mainly meant to just kind of wander around every location you can access until one of them has something that triggers the next part of the case. Usually, once this happens, you'll just be told where you need to go next, and when. As beautiful as the areas all are, aimlessly running around them trying to find the one that triggers the next flag is kind of boring.
Exacerbating this is the encounter rate, which is just insane at some points. There have been multiple times where I've finished a battle, and the next one starts less than one fully animated footstep later! It was most of the way into the second case where this problem got bad enough to completely kill any desire I had to continue playing. There's a section where you're in a maze of small rooms connected by pipes big enough to run through, and you've got to run back and forth through this maze utilising trial and error to figure out which levers need to be flipped to let you get a little further. The problem is that the levers and the doors they toggle aren't in the same rooms, so you have to make a guess, then run back to the doors, then if you guessed wrong, run back to the levers to try a again. All the while, you're constantly fighting off packs or rats and bats. They aren't challenging, but they do have just enough HP and appear in just big enough groups that each encounter takes at least two rounds to finish. It's tedious, annoying padding, and I just couldn't take any more.
If you've got more patience for this kind of thing than I do, then you'll probably be able to get really into London Seirei Tanteidan. It looks beautiful, the characters are charming, and if it were a TV show, I'd definitely watch it. It's just very unfortunate that it's a game, and I didn't enjoy playing nearly as much as I'd want to to continue with it. I do have this to say, though: I'm glad it has a human-made translation patch! I'd never even heard of it before the patch got released, and while I didn't like it, I'm sure it's a game that'll bring a lot of joy to the right kind of people. Furthermore, in this slop-blighted time, we're still in something of a golden age of Playstation translations made by talented, passionate groups of fans, and I know that reviews of Playstation games tend to be my most popular posts, so over the next few months, I'll be playing more of them. Please look forward to it!
%20(patched)-261116-230826.png)
%20(patched)-261116-232414.png)
%20(patched)-261117-000900.png)
%20(patched)-261117-140408.png)
%20(patched)-261117-132047.png)




